Appraisal Economics contact us | careers | print
Home / Who We Are
Range of Services
Representative Clients
Representative Transactions
Trusts and Estates
Options and Derivatives
Transfer Pricing
Goodwill Impairment
Power Plant Appraisals
Fairness and Solvency Opinions
Tangible Assets
Intangible Assets
Machinery and Equipment
Real Estate Appraisal
Real Estate Advisory Services
Family Limited Partnerships
Litigation Support
Cost Segregation Services
Recommended Links


Tangible Assets

Valuing Stock Options and Other Equity-Based Compensation

Appraisal Economics can value stock options and other equity based compensation for various purposes, including:
  • Financial reporting, principally under SFAS 123R
  • Gift and estate tax valuations
  • Other tax-related purposes


  • We have extensive experience valuing all types of equity based compensation, from simple call options to more complex derivatives, including:
  • Straight stock options
  • Restricted stock
  • Stock options with accreting exercise prices
  • Profits units
  • Outperformance units
  • Contingent purchase price elements


  • We have valued instruments that are subject to vesting conditions including earnings targets, share price targets, total return targets and, of course, time-based vesting.

    We apply a wide range of valuation techniques, including:
  • Closed form models such as Black-Scholes-Merton
  • Lattice models, such as a binomial model
  • Synthetic option modeling
  • Monte Carlo simulations



  • Valuing stock options and other types of equity-based compensation has become more important with the implementation of SFAS 123R. Commencing in the first fiscal year subsequent to June 15, 2005, all publicly traded companies are required to expense stock based compensation in accordance with SFAS 123R.

    Generally, SFAS 123R allows the use of a Black Scholes model, a lattice model, or any other model that meets three key criteria. The model must: (i) be applied in a manner consistent with the fair value measurement objective and other requirements of SFAS 123R, (ii) be based on established principles of financial economic theory as generally applied in that field and (iii) reflect all substantive characteristics of the grant instrument.

    It is important to note that certain types of performance conditions attached to equity-based instruments will trigger different types of accounting treatment. For example, target stock price conditions lead to fixed accounting treatment, in which the estimated fair value of the instrument is determined only as of the grant date, and its cost is amortized over the appropriate service period regardless of whether the conditions are subsequently met. Other performance conditions may lead to variable accounting treatment, in which the estimated fair value of the instrument is determined as of the grant date, but its cost is periodically adjusted to reflect subsequent performance.

    Appraisal Economics can help establish appropriate inputs into the valuation process, regarding such issues as expected volatility, historical option exercise behavior, expected forfeitures, and estimated option lives. This information is fully supported by a detailed narrative report suitable for review by independent auditors, the Securities and Exchange Commission, and the Internal Revenue Service.

    Whether you need a valuation of a complex derivative instrument with a detailed narrative report or ongoing valuation of simple stock options with minimal reporting, Appraisal Economics can provide fully supported high quality work in a timely and reliable manner.


    © 2008 - Appraisal Economics Inc. All Rights Reserved. All trademarks are owned by the respective companies or Appraisal Economics Inc.
    Home | Range of Services | Representative Clients | Representative Transactions | Trusts and Estates | Options and Derivatives | Transfer Pricing | Goodwill Impairment | Power Plant Appraisals | Fairness and Solvency Opinions | Tangible Assets | Intangible Assets | Machinery and Equipment | Family Limited Partnerships | Real Estate | Real Estate Advisory | Litigation Support | Cost Segregation Services | Recommended Links | Site Map